Gibson County Tennessee

                         The Homicide in Gibson County
submitted by

 

                     Memphis Daily Appeal, June 16, 1857

 

In last Saturday’s issue we referred to the murder of Mr. Pybas, in Trenton, on the Wednesday previous. The following additional particulars of this sad case we find in the Independent Journal, of last Saturday.

Distressing Homicide – The quiet of our usually peaceable town was disturbed last Wednesday, by the report of a pistol, and the alarm that Mr. Pybas , one of our most respectable and orderly citizens, was killed – shot down without a moments warning – while engaged in his shop at his trade, by a young man by the name of Emmerson B. Eddings, who has been reared in our midst and bore a character without reproach or stain.

Young Eddings is the only surviving son of a widowed mother, who resides in our town, and is the only support and protector of her and two sisters – one of whom has been engaged for some time past in teaching a juvenile school in this place. Mr. Pybas was one of her patrons, and on last Monday instituted a suit upon a State’s warrant against Miss Eddings upon a charge of maltreating his little son. The trial was held on last Monday evening before a magistrate, and after a thorough investigation of all the facts, Miss Eddings was honorably acquitted. Here it was hoped the matter would have rested, but information was communicated to young Eddings at South Gibson, where he resided and was transacting business, and perhaps too high a coloring given to the whole affair. This incensed him to such an extent with a belief that his sisters character was involved, that he came into town on Wednesday morning, doubtless for the purpose of seeking an explanation or some other satisfaction. Unfortunately, upon his arrival, he had to pass by Mr. Pybas’ shop to go to his mother’s residence, and possibly the temptation was too strong not to resist his calling in. When he stepped into the door, there were several gentlemen present, conversing with each other, who had not noticed his entrance until his salutation of “Good morning Mr. Pybas,” accompanied at the same instant by the report of the pistol. Mr. Pybas fell back and expired in a few minutes – the ball having taken effect in the right side near the right breast, ranging across through the heart, first passing through the right wrist, which was at the same time raised to his side. Mr. Eddings was immediately arrested by Officer A. C. Nolan, who was present at the time, but owing to the pursuit of Mr. Pybas’ sons, and to prevent him from being shot was again turned loose.

He went immediately and gave himself up to Esquire Hill, and in the afternoon his trial came off in the Court House. The room was crowded to overflowing by the anxious populace to learn everything connected with this distressing tragedy. After a very patient and thorough investigation of all the evidence, aided by the counsel on both sides, young Eddings was committed to jail to await his trial at the next term of the Circuit Court.

By this dreadful tragedy a gloom has been cast upon our town, which is sensibly felt by all, and it id difficult to tell where it’s sympathies are most bestowed – weather upon the large family who have been suddenly deprived of it’s head, in the full glow of health and without warning, or for the equally bereaved mother and sisters, whose only protector and solace is incarcerated for one of the highest offences known to our laws. Both were citizens equally well thought of and highly esteemed in this community, and the friends of one were the friends of both. The one an aged citizen with a large family around him, the other a young man who had grown up in it’s midst and been kindly and carefully nurtured by an affectionate and widowed mother. Both were quite, orderly and inoffensive citizens, and both had secured by their peaceful deportment many strong and warmly attached friends. But in an evil moment the tranquil sea has become ruffled, and the families of both plunged into an inconceivable anguish, casting a gloom upon the countenances of a sympathizing public. We would that a veil were thrown over this portion of our town’s history, and that we had never been called to chronicle it’s occurrence; but the fatal bullet has sped, and it’s victim lies weltering in his blood.

 

Mr. Pybas was buried with the honors of Odd Fellowship, on Thursday evening, of which order he and Mr. Eddings were both members.      

 

The Daily Dispatch (Richmond, Virginia) June 22, 1857

 

Fatal Affair in TennesseeMr. Nathaniel Pybas of Trenton, Tennessee, was instantly killed in his shop, on Wednesday last, By Emmerson B. Eddings: The following in regard to the occurrence, is copied from the Banner of that place:

Eddings sister teaches a school in Trenton, and Mr. Pybas prosecuted her before a magistrate for whipping one of his children. Her brother, residing in South Gibson , learning that, though the magistrate had fully and honorably acquitted Miss Eddings, her character had been unpleasantly involved, started to investigate the case. Arriving at Trenton he passed the shop of the deceased, and acting upon the impulse of the moment, entered and shot him without giving him a moment to prepare himself. Both parties were highly respectable citizens. Eddings is the son of a widowed mother, and her principal protector. The deceased leaves a large family.    

 

 

                  Memphis Daily Appeal, February15, 1859

 

Convicted and Sentenced – E. B. Eddings was convicted by the Circuit Court of Haywood, and sentenced to the penitentiary for ten years. Eddings, it will be remembered, killed Pybass in 1857, and removed his trial to Haywood.

 

These pages are courtesy of all the wonderful Gibson County TN volunteers who work so hard to make these pages
valuable to all researchers.  Please feel free to use them for your own personal research.  They are NOT the property
 of any corporation or any other genealogy project and are not to be used for any commercial purpose.    
All submitters to these pages retain the copyright.

Links to external web
sites are being provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only; they do not
constitute an endorsement or approval of any of the products, services or opinions contained
in any external web site.

Copyright 1998 - 2009 ©